Compare upgrades

CarPlay box vs CarPlay screen vs Android screen: which upgrade is right for your car?

8 min read Updated

In this guide 7
  1. The three upgrades compared
  2. Level 1: CarPlay box (keeps the factory screen)
  3. Level 2: CarPlay screen (new touchscreen, original controller)
  4. Level 3: Android screen (full Android head unit)
  5. How to choose
  6. Which Naviradio unit fits each system
  7. Frequently asked questions
BMW NBT Apple CarPlay Android car interface adapter F30 F10 F25 F15 Wireless

Short answer: a CarPlay box plugs into your car's factory system, keeps the original screen and controller, and adds Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. A CarPlay screen replaces the factory display with a new touchscreen that still works with the original iDrive or COMAND controller, but it has no apps of its own: everything runs from your phone. An Android screen is a complete Android head unit with its own apps and navigation, and on most models CarPlay and Android Auto built in. Keep your factory screen with a box, get a touchscreen with a CarPlay screen, or choose an Android screen if the car should work without a phone.

Naviradio sells all three, but which one fits depends on your model, year and factory system.

The three upgrades compared

CarPlay box CarPlay screen Android screen
Factory screen Stays Replaced Replaced
Original controller and steering wheel buttons Keep working Keep working Supported on most models
Factory radio and settings Stay Stay, you can switch back to them Kept on BMW, replaced on others such as the VW Golf 5 and 6
Apple CarPlay Wireless on most boxes Wireless or by cable Listed on most models
Android Auto By cable, wireless only with listed phones Wired or wireless, depends on the model Listed on most models
Without a phone Factory system, USB media on most boxes Factory system and USB media Own apps and navigation
Original reverse camera Supported Supported Supported on most models
AUX input needed Some boxes Most models Many BMW units
Install Plug and play, no coding Plug and play, the display is swapped Plug and play on most units, the display or radio is swapped

Level 1: CarPlay box (keeps the factory screen)

A CarPlay box connects to your car's original video plug and shows CarPlay and Android Auto on the screen you already have.

Who it suits: owners who like the factory screen and look, and want maps, music and calls from their phone.

What stays and what changes: the factory screen, controller, buttons and steering wheel buttons all stay. If the knob or touchpad controls your screen, it controls CarPlay. The original reverse camera and parking sensors keep working.

Install effort: plug and play, no coding. We confirm the right version for your car from a photo of your screen.

Typical limits: the picture stays at the factory screen size, and everything runs from your phone. Most listings state Android Auto by cable, and wireless only with certain listed phones. Some boxes, such as the BMW CIC box, need the car's AUX input. There is no box for BMW CCC or Mercedes NTG 4.0.

Level 2: CarPlay screen (new touchscreen, original controller)

A CarPlay screen replaces the factory display with a new touchscreen. It is not an Android system, but a multimedia screen with CarPlay and Android Auto built in. Where the BMW listings state a size, it is 8.8 or 10.25 inches.

Who it suits: owners who want a touchscreen but use their phone for apps, and owners whose system has no box.

What stays and what changes: only the display is replaced. The factory head unit stays, so the original radio, car settings, iDrive or COMAND controller, steering wheel buttons, parking sensors and reverse camera keep working. On many models, holding the Menu button for more than 2 seconds switches between CarPlay and the original system.

Install effort: plug and play with no coding on most models. Most screens send sound through the car's AUX input, so check that your car has one; if not, a local specialist can activate it. Some versions for cars without a factory screen, such as the 3 Series E90 one, need the dashboard cut using the supplied template.

Typical limits: without a phone you only have the original system and USB music and video. Wired or wireless Android Auto depends on the model - check the product page. Some no-screen versions do not fit right-hand drive cars, and several listings note that a new screen will not fix a factory unit that keeps restarting.

Level 3: Android screen (full Android head unit)

An Android screen is a complete head unit running Android 10 to 14, so it works without a phone. Depending on the model, it has 4 to 8 GB of RAM, 64 or 128 GB of storage and a 7 to 12.3-inch screen.

Who it suits: owners who want apps in the car itself. Many models list the Google Play Store, built-in navigation and a SIM card slot for 4G internet. It also suits the Audi A3 8P, which has no MMI.

What stays and what changes: on BMW it replaces the factory screen unit and keeps the factory radio. The Mercedes W205, W166 and W221 units let you switch between Android and the original system. On cars such as the VW Golf 5 and 6, Honda FR-V and Peugeot 407, it replaces the factory radio.

Install effort: plug and play on most units, and several 2-DIN units state an install time of 10-15 minutes. Many BMW units need the car's AUX input.

Typical limits: many BMW units and the Audi A4, A5 and Q5 units need a fully working original system. The Audi A3 8P and A4 B6/B7 units need an adapter for Bose speakers. Some listings, such as the BMW E60, E70 and E90 units, mention phone mirroring but not CarPlay, so ask us to confirm before you order.

How to choose

  1. Find your car. Pick your brand, model and year in the Fit Finder. For Mercedes, we confirm the NTG version from a photo of your radio screen.
  2. Want to keep your factory screen? Choose a CarPlay box, if one exists for your system: BMW CIC, NBT and NBT EVO, Mercedes NTG 4.5, 5.0, 5.5 and NTG 6 (MBUX), Audi MMI, VW MIB and Touareg RNS 850, and the other brands listed below. For Mercedes NTG 5.5 and NTG 6, the box is the only option we sell.
  3. No box for your system (BMW CCC, Mercedes NTG 4.0) or no factory screen? Choose a CarPlay screen or an Android screen.
  4. Happy to use your phone for everything? Choose a CarPlay screen. Want apps and navigation without a phone? Choose an Android screen.
  5. Still unsure? Send your model, year and a photo of your screen and controller through the contact page.

Which Naviradio unit fits each system

Frequently asked questions

Will I lose my factory radio or car settings?

Not with a box or a CarPlay screen: the factory system stays in place. With an Android screen it depends on the model: BMW units keep the factory radio, while units such as the VW Golf 5 and 6 version replace it.

Does my original reverse camera keep working?

Box and screen listings state support for the original reverse camera and parking sensors. Most Android screens state the same, but not all, so check the product page or ask us to confirm.

Do I need my phone for it to work?

For CarPlay and Android Auto, yes. Without a phone, a box or CarPlay screen gives you the original system and USB media, while an Android screen runs its own apps and navigation.

Is wireless Android Auto supported?

It depends on the unit. Most box listings state Android Auto by cable, and wireless only with listed phones. Screens and Android units differ by model, so check the product page.

What warranty do I get?

Every Naviradio unit, whichever of the three types you choose, comes with a 24-month warranty.

Guides

More guides

All guides →